< Rust | Introduction to Xenobiology | Vitrium >
Blue Crystal is a cold, high-albedo world world, slightly smaller than Earth, orbiting an F-class dwarf star. Despite orbiting a hotter star than our own Sun, its wide orbit means that Blue Crystal receives only 1/14th as much sunlight, and has an average surface temperature of -150C. The entire surface is covered in crystal-clear oceans of liquid nitrogen and tinged blue by dissolved liquid oxygen, with trace amounts of dissolved water and carbon dioxide, under an atmosphere of cold nitrogen gas. The solid surface is largely covered in "minerals" composed of dirty water and CO2 ices, with the occasional siliceous mountain peaks poking through.Those occasional siliceous peaks and periodic volcanic eruptions, along with the UV flux from its sun, are the key to life on Blue Crystal, as they are sources from which silanes--silicon-based analogs of hydrocarbons--dissolve into the liquid nitrogen sea.
Hydrosilicons are unstable in Earthlike conditions, but that makes them perfect for the Blue Crystal--while carbon-based organic chemistry reactions take far too long to support life in cryogenic conditions, silanes have just the reactivity needed to keep operating, without decomposing in excessive heat, and they dissolve relatively well--as well as anything does in a cryosolvent--in LN2.
Despite the cold temperatures and dim light, the Blue Crystal still supports a thriving, high-energy ecosystem. How? Well, the cold temperatures--only about half as hot as Earth--make most metabolic reactions more thermodynamically efficient. Heterotrophs make more efficient use of their food than Earthlings, and photosynthesis is about 5 times more efficient at capturing solar energy than on Earth. Additionally, the accessibility of d-orbitals, which enables higher coordination numbers for silicon compounds than for carbon, enables lower-energy pathways for fundamental biocatalyzed reactions like hydrolysis and ammonolysis. Thus, the total power available to the biosphere is about 1/3 as much as on Earth, rather than the 1/14th that might be naively predicted from simple insolation--and it needs less power to accomplish the same results as well.
Blue Crystal autotrophs operate surprisingly similarly to Earth plants, using CO2 as a carbon source and water as a hydrogen source--except they also chemically attack silica (SiO2) via alkaline hydroxyl and amide groups for an inorganic silicon source, using much more of it than carbon; and they release liquid, rather than gaseous, oxygen (not that it makes much difference when the oxygen simply mixes freely with the nitrogen sea, just as oxygen gas mixes freely with Earth's primarily-nitrogen atmosphere). Also unlike Earth life, the bulk biosolvent doesn't participate in much chemistry at all! LN2 is an inert bystander to the major metabolic reactions.
While LN2 makes up the majority of intracellular fluids and the forms the basis for extracellular blood, lymph, and sap analogs, it is not the only, nor even the most important, biochemically active solvent in Blue Crystal biology. While LN2 will dissolve hydrosilicons, thus leading to hydrosilicon polymers forming the major basis of Blue Crystal life, in objective terms it is not a very good solvent; that is why Blue Crystal looks the way it does, with its eponymous crystal-clear seas--aside from liquid oxygen, there just isn't that much stuff dissolved in the oceans to absorb or scatter light. Thus, just like Earth life uses fats to store certain molecules that are not water-soluble but are fat-soluble, Blue Crystal life uses mixtures of a variety of simple hydrocarbons and carbohydrates as alternative cryosolvents--and in fact, just as life on Earth is sometimes theorized to have originated around volcanic vents, it is thought that life on the Blue Crystal may have originated in cryovolcanic regions with higher temperatures (between -80C and -100C) where carbohydrates like ethanol are still liquid, before adapting to the larger LN2-dominated ocean environment. Blue Crystal lifeforms have been observed to use various mixtures of methanol, ethanediol, glycerol, acetone, methoxyethanol, and dimethylformamide as organelle-specific auxiliary solvents, which represent the majority of carbon usage by these organisms. None of these chemicals remain liquid in pure form at typical Blue Crystal temperatures, but eutectic mixtures of them do. This endogenous production of secondary organic solvents to augment LN2 chemistry has led some xenobiologists to formally classify Blue Crystal as a desert world, but due to the critical function of LN2 in Blue Crystal biology, this categorization is widely disputed.
Cellular membranes on Blue Crystal are formed primarily from azotosilanes, with weakly polar CN nitrile groups accumulating on the interior of a bilayer, and non-polar polysilane tails extending into the LN2 solvent--effectively the inverse of Earthling phospholipid bilayers, and similar to the azotosomes found on methane worlds. Organic solvent vesicles, on the other hand, are bounded by monolayers mediating between the weakly polar interior and non-polar exterior.
Simple microbial heterotrophs on Blue Crystal come in two varieties: anaerobic, and aerobic, just like on Earth. Anaerobic microbes get energy from simply decomposing silanes entirely, producing crystals of pure silicon and releasing hydrogen (and the occasional bit of silica, CO2, and water, when breaking down more complex molecules). There's nothing like Earthling methanogens, because, unlike methane, SiH4 takes energy to produce, rather than releasing energy when produced. Aerobic microbes breathe in liquid oxygen and release dissolved water and silica crystals.
Multicellular creatures, on the other hand, can't afford to pollute their cells with hard-to-excrete solid silica; as an Cannonball, the development of complex multicellular life was contingent on evolving means of eliminating solid crystalline metabolic wastes. Multicellular organisms on Blue Crystal get almost all of their energy by simply desaturating silanes, producing water and disilyne (H2Si2, along with other low-saturation hydrosilicons) as waste products, with disilyne serving as an additional source of slightly-more-available "organic" silicon for autotrophs, and as a food source for crystal-bearing microbes. While waste water is also solid in bulk form at Blue Crystal temperatures, its greater reactivity compared to silica allows it to be solvated and transported by specialized carrier molecules, much like oxygen and CO2 are bound for transport by hemoglobin and hemocyanin in Earthling animals. Note that there is no direct analog of hemoglobin as an oxygen carrier; such molecules are unnecessary in Blue Crystal life, as liquid oxygen is fully miscible with LN2.
In addition to the increased d-orbital coordination options afforded to silicon compared to carbon, silicon as a polymer backbone element also allows for greater electron delocalization through sp3 hybridization. This is an important feature in Blue Crystal biology which accommodates for the aprotic nature of Blue Crystal's biosolvents, which precludes the use of the proton gradients that are so ubiquitous in Earthling life as a central feature of energy transfer. Charge-separation chemistry in Blue Crystal life is thus accomplish intramolecularly, using large semiconductive polysilanes to shift electrons between reaction centers. Similarly, the function of ATP in Blue Crystal energy metabolism is filled by disilene (which is also an extremely common substrate molecule for synthesis reactions and intermediary product of fermentation), with energy stored and released through conformation alterations rather than bond formation and breakage.
While the details of the complete anabolic and catabolic ecological cycles are rather complex (just as they are on Earth), the reactions of the major energy-storage cycles, analogous to the glucose cycle on Earth, are as follows:
Silanologenic Photosynthesis: 2 SiO2 + 4 H2O -> 2 H3Si(OH) + O2
Silylsilanogenic Photosynthesis: 4 SiO2 + 6 H2O -> 2 H6Si2 + 7 O2
Silanol Fermentation: 2 H3Si(OH) -> H4Si2 + 2 H2O
Partial Disilene Respiration: 2 H4Si2 + O2 -> 2 H2Si2 + 2 H2O
Partial Disilane Respiration: 2 H6Si2 + 3 O2 -> 2 H2Si2 + 6 H2O
Disilyne Respiration (exclusive to microbial organisms): 2 H2Si2 + 3 O2 -> 2 SiO2 + 2 H2O
In addition to its role in Blue Crystal metabolic cycles, water is also a significant structural molecule on Blue Crystal, employed at all scales as a skeletal material. Diatom-like microbes form shells from pure water crystals; many autotrophs and sessile heterotrophs (analogs of Earthling fungi) augment their cell walls with water ice networks, analogously to the incorporation of amorphous silica into the cell walls of Earthling plants; and bulk water ice, used as a matrix for a composite material with silicon biopolymers, functions similarly to calcium carbonate and hydroxyapatite in Earthling biology to form tough, macroscopic shells and bones, with properties similar to pykrete.
Obviously these structure cannot exist under Earthlike conditions; Blue Crystal bones would literally melt. However, they are far from the most significant limiting factor when it comes to studying Blue Crystal life. As previously stated, most components of Blue Crystal biology are extremely unstable under Earthlike conditions, and Blue Crystal cells will begin to decompose and auto-oxidize well below the freezing point of water. Transport off-world requires constant refrigeration and maintenance of pressures in excess of 30 atmospheres. Direct human contact with the cryogenic organisms of Blue Crystal is infeasible under conditions that remain non-lethal for both parties, so most research must be conducted in-situ by robotic remotes.
The inspiration for this one originally came from from Jack Chalker's Wellworld series (<- Amazon affiliate link), in which one of the mysterious northern hemisphere environments is the "ocean of oxygen". Basic chemical information was derived from the paper Many Chemistries Could Be Used to Build Living Systems by William Baines. The description of azotosilane membranes is an extrapolation from the computational chemistry work from Can polarity-inverted membranes self-assemble on Titan?, based on the observation that silanes generally have lower freezing points than alkanes, and so should be less susceptible to falling into the solid crystalline state rather than the liquid crystal membrane state.
The inspiration for this one originally came from from Jack Chalker's Wellworld series (<- Amazon affiliate link), in which one of the mysterious northern hemisphere environments is the "ocean of oxygen". Basic chemical information was derived from the paper Many Chemistries Could Be Used to Build Living Systems by William Baines. The description of azotosilane membranes is an extrapolation from the computational chemistry work from Can polarity-inverted membranes self-assemble on Titan?, based on the observation that silanes generally have lower freezing points than alkanes, and so should be less susceptible to falling into the solid crystalline state rather than the liquid crystal membrane state.
While reading this entry, there were some points which left me slightly confused by how the details were written and then left in teh dark.
ReplyDeleteThe native polysilane-"backboned" surged originally at a slightly higher temperature medium of -80ºC to -100ºC, when they had access to ethanol before 'adapting to the greater LN2-dominated environment'. How did the scale tip in favour for a polysilane-base biochemistry back then? Life in the setting's "present" clearly can produce it at this point but were polysilanes just 'around'? Can they even be 'around' at such temperatures?
I was also confused by the justification on how photosynthesis would be five times more efficient at capturing incoming light despite the incoming light from the star being only a 1/14th to Earth's. Would it be too much to ask for more information, which led you to this conclusion?
The conceit is that high UV fluxes can convert silicon-rich rocks into silanes--so yes, they are just "around", and more reactive than hydrocarbons. The photosynthetic efficiency is related to thermodynamic limits. Higher temperatures reduce photosynthetic efficiency (in real life), in part because it is harder to reject entropy, and there is a lower limit to the energy of photons that can be used set by the thermal background. Cryogenic life can make use of more of the spectrum, and uses each photon more effectively, due to the better thermodynamic conditions.
DeleteDecided to do the maths. By Silicon-rich rocks, I have taken the term as synonymous to silicate rocks, so I decided to take a plausible, smallest unit that allows for the breakage of Si-O bonds and which allows for the formation of a Si-Si bond.
DeleteThe Silicon atoms will have a single bond with 4 Oxygen atoms, one of which they both bond to. The Bond Energy of a single Si-O bond is 452 kJ/mol, so about 7.506 * 10^-19 J per bond.
The Bond Energy of a single Si-Si bond, according to wikipedia, is 340 kJ/mol, so about 5.646 * 10^-19 J per bond.
To break the 8 Si-O bonds and then form the Si-Si one, the incident photon would have to carry an energy of 5.44·10^-18 J, which corresponds to a photon of the Extreme Ultraviolet range (36.52nm).
Blue Crystal's parent star is described as F-type. Their surface temperatures tend to generally be described as an interval of 6000K - 7400K. The photon which would allow for the Silanes from Silicates "pathway" could be emitted as the peak wavelength from a star which has a ~79350K surface temperature, which is incompatible with a F-type, but it also would mean that the emitted fraction of light which would be of such short wavelengths, coming from Blue Crystal's parent star, to allow for the conversion would be negligible. Probably by orders of magnitude.
Aside from that, while the Atmosphere is only described as containing 'cold nitrogen gas', the final paragraphs tell that native life to be transported offworld have to be kept in an atmosphere in excess of 30 atmospheres. Would such a [[DENSE]] atmosphere, even without ozone/oxygen in the way, even allow the extreme ultraviolets to reliably penetrate at such a large quantity to allow for a silanes-rich environment to the point it kickstarts this biochemistry? (and not to mention the cryogenic temperatures potentially just rendering the entire silicon-rich rock to silanes photoreaction completely defunct!)
Thinking back on the fact that this is a F-class Star, and that life runs on a cryosolvent, thus making its biological processes relatively way, WAY slower when compared Earthlike life processes, I have a feeling to add as an extra that I greatly doubt that multicellular life would reach very far.. specially when their sun will last less than Sol, but that's just a tiny extra that came to mind after reading one of your wb.SE posts mentioning aliens in a spaceship whose interiors were also, conveniently, at very similar conditions to what Blue Crystal offers (-150ºC, 20atm if I remembered well)
Yes, the Worldbuilding question is not unrelated. This whole idea started with the combination "Could there actually be an ocean of oxygen?" and "What if aliens had liquid nitrogen blood?"; those two ideas seemed complementary, and I tried to reverse-engineer from there.
DeleteSilicon carbide is also an option, and, while I don't off-hand know how much difference it would make, one has to account for the energy of hydrogen-oxygen and hydrogen-silicon bonds as well. I'll have to revisit the sources I used to devise this scenario in the first place. This version of Blue Crystal was the first draft of the idea, and I've already made various minor tweaks to it over the last 3.5 years, so I'm not averse completely replacing the star or rethinking the details of abiogenesis if it makes it more plausible.
Silicon Carbide's bonds dissociate at not such extreme UV, but the radiant flux could still be unfeasible to support a whole ecosystem with an F-type (And there comes the whole situation about how Silicon Carbide came into being, generally those worlds I see which have Silicon Carbide have it beacuse the C:O ratio is of a high value as the Silicon is not 'preserved' in the form of Silica, might require special justifications perhaps to keep the metabolic pathways the same?)
Delete